2-Day SHIPPING ON US — ANY TWO OR MORE 6PKS
Menu
Search Search Basket
0
Cart
4.9
Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
206

First Taste Experience

$38.00
$28.00

$38 VALUE → $19 (WITH CODE)

First-Time Customer Offer
Use Code: STANDARDS

A Taste for Every Craving
99% Organic • Gluten Friendly
No Naughty Ingredients®

Your first (and best) way in: a curated mix of our best-loved treats across every craving. Experience why we’re known for making the best treats on the internet.

Includes Good Housekeeping’s BEST BROWNIE & BEST OAT BAR award winners.

Upgrade Your First Taste Offer?
Save more with the 18pk Bundle

Offer limited to First Box or Bundle (1).
Cannot be combined with other offers.
6 Pack
In stock

Why It's Better

Made with Raaka
Straus Family Creamery Logo
made with One trick pony peanut butter
Nielsen Massey Logo
Made with Crown Maple
Over 99% Organic Ingredients
NON GMO
1% for the Planet Logo

What You Get

Designed for first-time customers to discover what makes LEXINGTON BAKES extraordinary.

One order. Six bestsellers. Built for every craving:

  • 2 Protein Oat Bars: Treat with Substance.
  • 2 Protein Cookies: Feel-Good Treat. Satisfies.
  • 2 Brownies: Dessert You Don't Question.

Flavors & Taste

  • Maple Brown Butter: Rich. Buttery-sweet.
  • Raspberry Crumble: Bright. Fruity & Tart.
  • Peanut Butter Chip: Salty-sweet. Charming.
  • Berry Blackout: Dramatic. Intriguing.
  • Fleur de Sel: Chocolatey. Salty-sweet.
  • Hazelnut Crunch: Nostalgic Cocoa-Hazelnut.

Built for Real Life.
Not Rules.

Treats you reach for every craving.

Mornings • Afternoons  • After dinner
Late-night • Hosting • Celebrations

One of the Best Bakeries on the Internet

TWO Good Housekeeping 2025 Snack Awards:

  • 🏆 BEST BROWNIE: Hazelnut Crunch
  • 🏆 BEST OAT BAR: Maple Brown Butter

We didn’t design our treats to win awards.
We designed them to taste extraordinary, and people noticed.

Flavor First.
Support Second.

Protein and fiber show up where they belong—supporting the experience, never defining it.

Bakery-made treats for real life.

Texture Notes

  • Oat Bars: soft-baked • chewy • comforting
  • Cookies: thick • chewy • deeply satisfying
  • Brownies: rich • fudgy • worth-it indulgence

Pair with espresso, cold milk, or a latte.

Like No Other
Dessert in the World®

This is just the beginning.
Explore full boxes of the treats you’ll come back to.

Offer limited to First Box or Bundle (1).
Cannot be combined with other offers.

Shop All Treats →

Ingredient Transparency

Our Radical Ingredient Transparency® goes above and beyond the standard ingredient list to provide unprecedented transparency and traceability.

We take transparency to a higher standard.
Real ingredients. Fully disclosed. Zero nonsense.

You’ll see the same standards across every treat in the box:

  • Organic + Fair Trade ingredients
  • No artificial sweeteners, flavors, dyes, or preservatives
  • No sugar alcohols, gums, weird oils, or “natural flavors” shortcuts

Ingredients: See individual flavor pages for full ingredient lists and allergen information.

Treats May Contain: Milk, Egg, Almond, Peanut, Hazelnut, Sesame.Made on equipment that also processes: Wheat.

No Naughty Ingredients®

No artificial sweeteners, flavors, preservatives or dyes.
No sugar alcohols, soy, gums, corn syrups, bleached flour, or weird oils. Ever.

Enjoy & Store

Treats ship frozen for freshness and arrive ready-to-enjoy at room temperature.

Store:

  • Refrigerate upon arrival for up to 60 days.
  • Take on-the-go for up to 7 days.
  • Or keep frozen until the best-by date.

Enjoy:

  • Oat Bars: straight from the fridge, room temp, or warmed briefly
  • Cookies: chilled, room temp, or warmed for melty chocolate vibes
  • Brownies: chilled for truffle-like density, warmed for molten richness

To warm: Place unwrapped treat on a parchment-lined tray. Warm in a 350°F oven for 3–5 minutes. Cool slightly. Do not microwave.

Shipping & Delivery
  • Orders outside of CA ship Monday through Wednesday to avoid weekend delays.
  • Our shipping partners deliver orders Monday through Saturday.
  • For time-sensitive events and celebrations, we recommend scheduling your order to arrive 1-2 days early to account for any transit delays. Please refer to storage instructions for each your bakes.
  • More shipping questions? Read our Shipping FAQs.
FAQs

What is the First Taste Experience?
A curated mix of our best-loved Oat Bars, Protein Cookies, and Brownies—designed to cover every craving and every moment.

Is this the best place to start?
Yes. If you’re new, it’s the easiest way to try the full lineup and find your repeat-buy favorites.

What’s the deal?
$40 total value for $20 with free shipping.

Can returning customers order this?
No. The First Taste Experience is limited to first-time customers only.

Can I customize the box?
No. It’s intentionally curated to represent the full LEXINGTON BAKES experience.

Are these diet or protein snacks?
No. These are real bakery desserts. Some include protein and fiber for satisfaction—but flavor and texture always come first.

Are the treats vegan or gluten free?
Some are vegan, some aren’t. Many are gluten friendly. Check each item’s ingredient list for exact details.

Do flavors rotate?
If seasonal items are included, they may rotate and are available for a limited time.

LEXINGTON BAKES Maple Brown Butter Protein Oat Bar Nutrition Facts
Pouch measures 3 x 3"
Actual treat approx. 2 x 2"
More details

My Morning Joy

Oats? Glyphosate free. Sugar? Low. All real-food ingredients. You’ve completed me.

Maple Brown Butter
Protein Oat Bar

Love These Cookies!

These little gems are the perfect size, texture, and the ingredients are top notch!

Peanut Butter Chip
Protein Cookie

The most decadent brownie you’ll ever have

If you like your brownies more fudge like, these are your brownies. The most delicious and truly addicting brownie. I couldn’t put it down. And the salt on top really balances everything out.

Fleur de Sel
Brownie

Shop All

View all
Offer

206 reviews First Taste Experience
$28.00 $38.00
Offer

63 reviews First Taste Trio Bundle
$69.00 $84.00
Lexington Bakes maple brown butter protein oat bar in packaging, held in hand

18 reviews Maple Brown Butter Protein Oat Bars
$28.00
Lexington Bakes peanut butter chocolate chip protein cookie in packaging

12 reviews Peanut Butter Choc Chip Protein Cookies
$28.00
Lexington Bakes Hazelnut Crunch brownie in packaging, held in hand

32 reviews Hazelnut Crunch Brownies
$28.00
Lexington Bakes Berry Blackout protein cookie in packaging, held in hand
New Arrival

12 reviews Berry Blackout Protein Cookies
$28.00
Lexington Bakes raspberry crumble protein oat bar in packaging, held in hand

31 reviews Raspberry Crumble Protein Oat Bars
$28.00
Lexington Bakes Fleur de Sel brownie in packaging, held in hand

89 reviews Fleur De Sel Brownies
$28.00
Lexington Bakes cocoa cereal protein oat bar in packaging, held in hand
New Arrival

2 reviews Cocoa Cereal Protein Oat Bars
$28.00
Lexington Bakes vanilla almond chocolate chip protein cookie in packaging
New Arrival

3 reviews Vanilla Almond Choc Chip Protein Cookies
$28.00
LEXINGTON BAKES™ Choc Chip N°5® cookie in packaging, held in hand

26 reviews Choc Chip N°5® Cookies
$28.00

Top First Taste Experience Reviews

4.9
Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
Based on 206 reviews
Total 5 star reviews: 198 Total 4 star reviews: 6 Total 3 star reviews: 0 Total 2 star reviews: 1 Total 1 star reviews: 1
Slide 1 selected
Write a Review (Opens in a new window)
206 reviews
  • JM
    John M.
    Verified Buyer
    First Taste Experience
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    6 hours ago
    Delicious

    The variety package was delicious and so fresh.

    Was this helpful?
  • NS Profile picture for Nancy S.
    Nancy S.
    Verified Buyer
    First Taste Experience
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    19 hours ago
    Surprisingly delicious

    I was so surprised at how fresh and chewy and delicious these taste. My favorite is the maple. I’m getting ready to order some more.

    Was this helpful?
  • WG
    Wendy G.
    Verified Buyer
    First Taste Experience
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    23 hours ago
    Yummy snacks

    I’ve only tried the maple brown butter protein bar. It was really good. Looking forward to tasting the others.

    Was this helpful?
  • JF
    Janie F.
    Verified Buyer
    First Taste Experience
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    23 hours ago
    Simply Delicious Sample Pack

    I enjoying these very much! I have tried three so far.

    Was this helpful?
  • W
    william
    Peanut Butter Choc Chip Protein Cookies
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    3 days ago
    5 Stars

    Great cookies delicious cold or baked in the oven.

    Was this helpful?
  • W
    william
    Maple Brown Butter Protein Oat Bars
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    3 days ago
    5 Stars

    Great oat bars delicious cold or baked in the oven.

    Was this helpful?
  • W
    william
    Hazelnut Crunch Brownies
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    3 days ago
    5 Stars

    Great brownies very clean and delicious cold or baked in the oven.

    Was this helpful?
  • L
    Lynn
    First Taste Experience
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    3 days ago
    5 Stars

    Very pleased with these samples....my husband liked them as well. I'd definitely recommend.

    Was this helpful?
  • AM
    Aaron m.
    Verified Buyer
    Maple Brown Butter Protein Oat Bars
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    6 days ago
    Love it.

    Really good. Wish more stores carried them. Best tasting bar by far.

    Was this helpful?
  • SR
    Steve R.
    Verified Buyer
    First Taste Experience
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1 week ago
    Untimely surprised.

    I was impressed on how originally good they were. I would like to reorder.

    Was this helpful?
Show More
×