In the Mix

Why LEXINGTON BAKES is one of The Best Brownies in the World

Here’s why our brownies consistently earn a spot among the best brownies on the internet.

Real. Organic. Fair Trade. Brownies.

Our ingredient standards are simple. Real, Organic, & Fair. When sourcing ingredients for our luxury cookies and brownies, we thoroughly evaluate ingredient partners’ standards, ethics, and commitment to people and the planet to ensure they align with our mission and values.

For us, a brownie isn’t just dessert. It’s an American icon. And we’ve reimagined it as a New American Classic with real, organic, fair ingredients that honors nostalgia while pushing the boundaries of flavor, sourcing, and craftsmanship.

Here’s why our brownies consistently earn a spot among the best brownies on the internet.

Award-Winning Brownie Flavor, Texture and Quality

LEXINGTON BAKES organic chocolate brownies are not just loved by customers; they’ve been recognized by industry leaders including Good Housekeeping, "The flavor is on point, sweet without being too sweet and just the right amount of chocolate.”

Honored as Good Housekeeping Best Snack Awards, rated by registered dietitians and top food critics.
Among the best brownies in The Chocolate Professor’s Top 8 Mail-Order Brownies.
Highlighted as one of Forbes best valentine’s day gifts, for shared or self indulgence

No Naughty Ingredients®

With LEXINGTON BAKES, you never have to question if it’s good for you. We leave out all the naughty ingredients, so you can have your brownie and feel good too.

We won’t all agree on what constitutes a naughty ingredient; for us, it means our treats are free from controversial ingredients, including artificial sweeteners, flavors, preservatives and dyes, sugar alcohols, soy, gums, corn syrups, bleached flour, hydrogenated oil, and more.

We respect that artificial sweeteners have a place in the food world and, for many, provide alternative access to consuming sweet treats. But as the safety of these ingredients is not definitively confirmed globally, we can’t, in good consciousness, use them in our treats.

Radical Ingredient Transparency®

We go above and beyond the standard industry ingredient list to provide unprecedented transparency and traceability by listing our specific ingredient brands and partners on our products. So you never have to wonder, “What’s in this?”

Our treats leave you wondering about the extraordinary effort that went into bringing such globally celebrated ingredients together rather than worrying if naughty ingredients are lurking in your treats. One look at our Radical Ingredient Transparency on our packaging and website, and you know without a doubt, these are the best brownies in the world.

Like No Other Dessert in the World®

Fleur de Sel Brownie: Our signature rich fudgy brownie topped with delicate sea salt crystals that amplify chocolate’s natural complexity.

Hazelnut Crunch Brownie: Inspired by your favorite chocolate hazelnut spread, this brownie is made with ground up hazelnuts, which makes it gluten free without compromise.

Raspberry Velvet® Brownie: Our limited edition take on red velvet without the toxic food dyes. A velvety brownie with bright and tangy raspberries and swirls of smooth cream cheese icing.

Pumpkin Spice Espresso Brownie: Our limited edition Fall brownie with Jaguar espresso, spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg, clove, and ginger, and topped with swirls of pumpkin cream cheese icing.

Our luxury brownies make for a perfect bite every time with a soft fudgy center and a crispy top layer. Enjoy chilled for a fudgy texture, at room temperature for a cakey texture, or warm up for a gooey, lava-cake-like experience.

Beautifully Packaged Luxury Brownie Gift Boxes

Our brownies aren’t just delicious, they arrive beautifully packaged, making them the perfect gift. Our white marble treat boxes are crafted to feel as luxurious as what’s inside, so when you send LEXINGTON BAKES, you’re sharing more than dessert. You’re sharing a luxury treat experience they’ll never forget.

Why We Belong on Every “Best Brownies” List

When publications and food lovers search for the best brownies online, they often highlight scale, tradition, or novelty. LEXINGTON BAKES stands apart because we offer:

Award-winning flavor and quality rated by dietitians, food critics and fans.
Ethical organic and fair trade sourcing that supports farmers and the planet.
Unforgettable flavor that elevates a childhood treat into a grown up moment of self care.

That’s why food authorities, from The Chocolate Professor to Good Housekeeping and Forbes, have named us among the best mail order brownies. And it’s why, once you’ve tasted a LEXINGTON BAKES brownie, no other brownie will ever compare.

Get the Best Brownies Online Shipped Right to Your Door

Discover why food critics, chocolate connoisseurs, and thousands of happy customers agree that LEXINGTON BAKES is among the best brownies in the world.

More in the mix

View all

Why LEXINGTON BAKES is one of The Best Brownies in the World

Here’s why our brownies consistently earn a spot among the best brownies on the internet.

Gluten-Free Brownies That Don’t Compromise on Flavor

The best gluten-free brownies aren’t about compromise. With roasted hazelnut praline and organic, Fair Trade chocolate, LEXINGTON BAKES’ Hazelnut Crunch Brownie delivers rich, fudgy indulgence that rivals any classic.

Gift the Best Brownies: Why Gourmet Brownies Are the Perfect Gift

This holiday season, give a gift that’s both nostalgic and luxurious. LEXINGTON BAKES gourmet brownies, made with organic, Fair Trade chocolate and wrapped in elegant boxes, are the perfect holiday treat for family, friends, and colleagues.

The Best Mail-Order Brownies You Can Buy Online

There’s no need to settle for supermarket sweets: 2025’s best mail-order brownies bring bakery-quality indulgence straight to your doorstep. From fudgy classics to gourmet creations like LEXINGTON BAKES’ award-winning brownies, these top picks deliver rich flavor, beautiful presentation, and nationwide shipping.