In the Mix

The Best Mail-Order Brownies You Can Buy Online

There’s no need to settle for supermarket sweets: 2025’s best mail-order brownies bring bakery-quality indulgence straight to your doorstep. From fudgy classics to gourmet creations like LEXINGTON BAKES’ award-winning brownies, these top picks deliver rich flavor, beautiful presentation, and nationwide shipping.

There’s nothing quite like a fresh, fudgy brownie. And in today’s world, you don’t need to live near a bakery to indulge, you can have the best brownies delivered straight to your door. Mail-order brownies have become a booming category in gourmet food, with dozens of bakeries shipping nationwide. But which ones are truly worth it?

Here’s our 2025 guide to the best mail-order brownies you can buy online, from classic fudgy squares to innovative luxury takes on the American favorite.

What to Look for in Mail-Order Brownies

Not all brownies travel well, and not all shipping-friendly brownies are created equal. When evaluating which mail-order brownies make the cut, consider:

  • Ingredients: Are they made with real chocolate or cocoa powder shortcuts? Do they use preservatives or palm oil?
  • Texture: The best brownies strike the right balance: dense, fudgy, and moist without crumbling or drying out in transit.
  • Packaging: Individually wrapped pieces or airtight beautiful boxes ensure freshness when shipping across the country.
  • Presentation: If sending as a gift, packaging matters: luxury packaging makes brownies feel as special as they taste.
  • Reviews & Recognition: Awards, press mentions, and customer ratings all signal standout quality.

The Top Mail-Order Brownies of 2025

LEXINGTON BAKES

No list of the best brownies is complete without LEXINGTON BAKES, recently named to The Chocolate Professor’s Top 8 Mail-Order Brownies. Known for their No Naughty Ingredients® promise and Radical Ingredient Transparency®, LEXINGTON BAKES delivers luxury brownies that reimagine the nostalgic treat.

With awards from Good Housekeeping Best Snack Awards and rave customer reviews, LEXINGTON BAKES sets the gold standard for mail-order brownies in both flavor and integrity.

Fairytale Brownies

An Arizona-based staple in the mail-order brownie world, Fairytale Brownies has been shipping nationwide since the 1990s. They offer variety boxes with flavors like walnut, cream cheese swirl, and espresso, and their individually wrapped packaging makes them popular for gifting.

Killer Brownie

Born in Dayton, Ohio, Killer Brownie is famous for decadent triple-layer brownies with gooey caramel and inclusions like pecans or cookie dough. Their indulgence factor is sky-high, though some may find them a bit too sweet compared to chocolate-forward brownies.

Fat Witch Bakery

Fat Witch Bakery started in a modest New York kitchen, where its founder left a finance career behind to bake homemade brownies for coworkers. Today, the brand offers over 100 unique brownie variations worldwide, including shops in Kyoto and Osaka.

Zingerman’s Bakehouse

This Ann Arbor institution is renowned for its gourmet baked goods. Their brownies lean classic and come in varieties like Buenos Aires Brownie with dulce de leche. They’re a favorite among food critics and a must-try for fans of rich, home-style baking.

Why LEXINGTON BAKES Stands Apart

While all of these bakeries make delicious brownies, LEXINGTON BAKES is redefining just how good mail-order brownies can be:

When you order from LEXINGTON BAKES, you can enjoy satisfying indulgence with peace of mind.

Final Bite: Brownies Delivered to Your Door

The best mail-order brownies in 2025 prove that you don’t need to settle for supermarket sweets. Whether you’re sending a gift or treating yourself, the right brownie can be a moment of joy delivered in a box.

And if you’re looking for the best of the best, LEXINGTON BAKES luxury brownies deserve to be first on your list.

Order a New American Classic Brownie

Discover why food critics, chocolate lovers, and thousands of happy customers agree: LEXINGTON BAKES is elevating brownies to a new level of feel good indulgence.

×